Q. I am having trouble differentiating between mild thalassemia and iron-deficiency anemia. I am not sure why the red cell distribution width would be lower in thalassemia than IDA. Could you please explain this and list other ways to tell them apart?
A. Great question! This is a common problem, especially when we’re talking about mild thalassemia (which we tend to see more often than severe thalassemia.
First: Why is it hard to tell mild thalassemia apart from iron-deficiency anemia? Because they’re the two most common hypochromic, microcytic anemias! So they’ll both show an increased MCHC (mean cell hemoglobin concentration) and they’ll both have a decreased MCV (mean cell volume, or average red cell size). They can look pretty similar on blood smear examination, too, unless you know a few tricks. So let’s look at the red cell distribution (RDW) first, since that’s the main part of your question – and then we’ll move on to some other little tricks you can use.
Red cell distribution width (RDW)
The RDW is one good thing to look at when you’re trying to tell these two anemias apart. Just a reminder: this red cell test tells you how much the red cells vary in size. Another word for this variance is anisocyotosis.
Normal blood has minimal anisocytosis and a low RDW (because the red cells are all pretty much the same size). Some cases of anemia have a high RDW (meaning that some red cells are relatively smaller and some are relatively larger – in other words, there’s a range of sizes.
Important aside: the RDW has nothing to do with the mean cell volume (MCV)! The MCV tells you the average size of the patient’s red cells. The RDW tells you how much the patient’s cells vary in size (but it doesn’t give you any information on the actual mean size of the patient’s red cells!). So the RDW and MCV are independent variables.
Why would the RDW be different in iron-deficiency anemia and mild thalassemia? Because iron-deficiency anemia is a disease that has a starting point and is progressive. In other words, at some point, the patient’s iron drops below the normal range, and then the iron level drops progressively lower and lower
This progressive nature of the disease means that each new wave of red cells coming out of the bone marrow is smaller than the last. And since normal red cells hang around for about 4 months, you’ll see some older cells that are close to normal in size, and then newer cells that are getting smaller and smaller (as you can see in the image of iron-deficiency anemia above). So the red cell distribution width (RDW) is increased in iron deficiency anemia because there is a increased variation in red cell size (some relatively smaller, some relatively larger).
In mild thalassemia (alpha or beta), the disease doesn’t just start at some point in the patient’s life: it is a genetic abnormality that doesn’t change over time (it’s always the same; you’re not making enough alpha chains or enough beta chains). So the red cells are all pretty much the same size. So the RDW is normal (or sometimes even low!), since the patient’s red cells show virtually no variation in relative size.
This difference in RDW is helpful when you’re trying to differentiate IDA and thalassemia; if you have a microcytic, hypochromic anemia, the next thing you’d do is look at the RDW (or just look at the blood smear). If the RDW is low (the cells are mostly the same size), then it’s probably thalassemia. If the RDW is high (the cells vary a lot in size), then it’s probably iron deficiency anemia.
Red blood cell count (RBC)
Another thing to do is look at the RBC. In IDA, the RBC is low (there isn’t enough iron around, so the bone marrow makes fewer cells). In mild thalassemia, however, the RBC tends to be normal or even elevated. The reasons for this are unclear – but I think maybe the marrow is trying to compensate for the decreased red cell size and hemoglobin content by making more cells. That’s just my theory though.
Poikilocytosis
Poikilocytosis refers to the shape of the red cells. In normal blood, there is minimal poikilocytosis (all the red cells are basically round). In both IDA and mild thalassemia, there are a couple poikilocytes (unusually-shaped red cells) that can show up. You wouldn’t want to “hang your hat” on these when making a diagnosis (strange but true commonly-used phrase amongst the pathology cognocsenti).
In IDA, you’ll sometimes see elongated, thin red cells for some reason. These are called elliptocytes, and they aren’t seen in mild thalassemia. In thalassemia, you often see target cells, which are not a common finding in IDA.
Thrombocytosis
The normal platelet count is roughly 150,000 – 450,00 platelets/µL. In IDA, you’ll often see a mild reactive thrombocytosis (up to, say, 600 platelets/µL). This is clinically insignificant – but it can be nice little diagnostic sign that can help you lean towards IDA. In thalassemia, the platelet count is generally normal.Â
Bottom line
All of these things we’ve talked about here are general rules, and they can definitely help point you towards the correct diagnosis. They’re particularly helpful if you’re on a pathology rotation and facing a tray of unknown slides, or just being quizzed by a particularly tough attending at a multiheaded scope. In those scenarios, the idea is to get as close to the right diagnosis based just on the slide (and hopefully an MCV, since that is something you cannot determine by looking at a blood smear).Â
In the real world, though, with a real patient, you don’t want to guess. You want definitive testing to back up your diagnosis, no matter how sure you might be. So to definitively diagnose IDA, you need to do iron studies, and to definitively diagnose thalassemia, you need to do hemoglobin electrophoresis. But you can get a pretty good head start on the diagnosis by looking at the things discussed above.






Hello guys..
I got a simple calculation based just on CBC (Complete Blood Count)
FORMULA—
DF = (MCV)2 x RDW – CV / Hb. x 100
Where- DF= Discriminent Function
(MCV, RDW, Haemoglobin are CBC based values)
Thus if DF value 70 Suspect for IDA
🙂
informative
To separate thalassemia trait and IDA
1.Hb in TT is not less than 10g/dl but in IDA it is less upto 3g/dl.
2.RBC is more than 5million but in IDA it is less.
3.RDW is less than 17% in TT but in IDA it is more than 17%.
not forgetting the mentzer index as well — ratio of MCV and RBC – if more than 13 then its likely IDA. if less than 13 its suggestive of thal.
Yes – good point! As you suggest in your comment, this test is not a definitive test (it’s pretty specific but not all that sensitive).
how can we differentiate target cell is due to liver disease or thalassemia?
You’d have to look at the whole smear, the CBC (specifically, the MCV, RBC and RDW), and the patient’s clinical status.
In uncomplicated liver disease (in which there is no iron-deficiency anemia due to bleeding, and no folate deficiency), the anemia is macrocytic, and there may be acanthocytes.
More often, though, there are complications in patients with liver disease: bleeding (leading to iron deficiency and a microcytic anemia) or nutritional abnormalities like folate deficiency (leading to a megaloblastic anemia). The anemia may even be a mixture of all of these features!
Mild thalassemia is microcytic, with a normal or elevated RBC and very mild anisocytosis. Severe thalassemia is also microytic, but the RBC is low and there is a ton of anisocytosis.
So: there are a lot of different features to be aware of. You may need to do look at the patient’s other labs (liver function tests, etc) and/or do hemoglobin electrophoresis to figure things out.
Hope that helps.
dear sir/mam;
thank you for the very informative haematology topic…as a Biomedical Scientist…with this additional reinforcement of info as knowledge application it will help me more validate correct clinical lab results for final analysis and lab diagnosis therefore exact prescription and patient`s medication…:::
Alhamdulillah…
Thanks a LOT!!!!!!!!!!
To differentiate anemia and Thalassemia-
1. You get mark anisopoikilocytosis in anemia and
2. The Mentzer index which is defined as mean corpuscular volume per red cell count. An index of less than 13 suggests that the patient has the thalassemia trait, and an index of more than 13 suggests that the patient has iron deficiency.
reason for the RBC count to be normal or elevated is because defect lies at globin chain formation level but no nutritional deficiency otherwise .so process of formation of red cells remains normal or slightly elevated to compensate for early disposal of RBCs.and ps definately helps to differentiate between the two and indices also.
very good!
thank you
Thanks.
Thank you so much.
Very helpful , Thanks every1
helped me a lot; thank u so much.
RBC=5.15 HB=13.7 Hct=40.8 MCV=79.3 MCH=26.6
MCHC=33.4 RDW=14.2 WBC=4.9
can you help me? iron-deficiency anemia or
thalassemia?
please..
Probably thalassemia, given the low MCV and normal hemoglobin – but you’d need to do iron studies to be sure 🙂
Thank you very much for your help….it makes things at the lab
thanks every one very informative discussion
I am really thankful for the good, simple and clear explanation. I rally Like the information and I understand it very well. Thank you again.
How do you differentiate between between beta thalassemia alpha and beta using heamahlobin electrophoresis and full red cell counts.
Thanks so much everyone